BAC 2022: was the SES test politically oriented? On the internet, an anthology of reactions.

Thursday, May 12, high school students took their specialty exams for the 2022 baccalaureate. The subject of SES (economic and social sciences) sparked a deluge of criticism on social networks, on the grounds that these would be oriented towards liberalism. Was the test really biased? In recent days, reactions have rocketed.

bac 2022 lepreuve de ses etait elle politiquement orientee florilege de reactions
Photo: Shutterstock

At the origin of the controversy: one of the subjects offered to graduates who have chosen the specialty of Economics and Social Sciences. Candidates were notably invited to show that innovation can help push back the ecological limits of growth “, or even to ” to show that the action of public authorities in favor of social justice can produce perverse effects. » The topic in question, available at national education website was broadcast an hour after the start of the test by a philosophy teacher who was monitoring it.

The Association of Professors of Economics and Social Sciences (Apses) reacted on Friday. According to this group of teachers, it is first of all the formulation of the subjects that raises questions: The problem therefore comes from these exercises which require reciting, without stepping back, without debate or problematization.. »

This topic is ” The tree that hides the forest » denounces again the Apses, because it is in the image of the program taught throughout the year: « A symptom of the insufficient consideration of environmental issues in the programs. An argument taken up by Léna Clément, associate professor at SES. His brother, the famous journalist Hugo Clément, relayed his opinion on his Instagram page.

Explaining that the program taught has evolved since the arrival of Jean-Michel Blanquer at the ministry, Léna Clément denounces a biased teaching favoring a single vision of the economy: one which considers that ” natural and technological capital are substitutable. »

Loup Espargilière, journalist and founder of the media Greenmeanwhile has “ passed his baccalaureate on a Twitter thread. He demonstrated by a+b how the wording of the subject is problematic: he implies that “ growth is essential » and that the ecological limits must be « postponed. The journalist notably recalled that, historically, GDP growth has gone hand in hand with the growth of CO2 emissions.

On Twitter, sociologist Denis Colombi took the opposite view of the controversy, qualifying the debate around the test: “ Here, we ask them to mobilize part of the lesson (…) It is the skill that we want to test – rather than seeing if they can recite a lesson plan as it is, see if they can choose what happens. relates to this question. It is already important to understand the exercise and its form. »

Rather than throwing stones at the wording of the subject of the BAC, he invited in a Tweet posted yesterday to rethink the form of the programs by enriching the part dedicated to environmental economics.

Was the subject of the SES BAC really… borderline? Your turn to judge !

We want to give thanks to the writer of this post for this awesome web content

BAC 2022: was the SES test politically oriented? On the internet, an anthology of reactions.

Take a look at our social media profiles along with other related pages